Britain’s MI5 faces scrutiny for deceiving the public and the courts about its connections to the Manchester Arena bomber and its protection of a violent neo-Nazi informant. Leaked emails show the intel agency secretly working to gut legislation that would bar British officials and spies from lying when addressing state investigations.
On October 21, Britain’s Public Office (Accountability) Bill, known as the Hillsborough Law, completed its committee stage in the House of Lords. The legislation, which would establish a “duty of candour” making it a criminal offense for government agents to lie to or conceal information from inquiries and investigations, is now due for a vote by the Lords. Members of Parliament’s upper chamber can delay the legislation for a year, potentially killing it altogether, or attempt to force amendments to its terms.
Emails unearthed by The Grayzone show that for years, Britain’s domestic spy agency, MI5, has covertly managed a campaign against Hillborough in parliament. In the House of Lords, former MI5 directors have kept a “list” of “allies” who could be relied on to weaken the bill or kill it altogether. McCallum personally tried to negotiate what he called “a bearable version of the Hillsborough Law” with Prime Minister Andy Burnham before he took office.
The proposed law is named for an April 1989 overcrowding incident which killed 97 Liverpool fans at Hillsborough stadium in Sheffield. A public inquiry and separate inquest much later found local police falsified and suppressed evidence to wrongly blame Liverpool football club supporters for the mass carnage, which was actually caused by police, while peddling libelous allegations against innocent fans, painting them as drunken hooligans. The Hillsborough Law would impose criminal penalties of 2 to 14 years in prison for government workers who lie to public investigators.
In the Labour party’s 2024 manifesto, Keir Starmer pledged to implement the bill. But Labour has since dragged its feet after coming under pressure from members of Parliament who worried that MI5, MI6 and GCHQ would be insulated from scrutiny. The Commons finally passed the legislation in July. With the Lords vote looming, campaigners fear the intelligence services will find a way to insulate themselves from the obligation to tell the truth, as the legislation mandates.
